The Brownstone Whisperer

My name is Bruce Warila, and I’m a Senior Executive at Building Restoration Services, based here in Boston.

If you own a brownstone and are facing any of the issues described below, I’m confident that our Building Sciences and Construction Services divisions can help. These aren’t just technical problems—they’re the kinds of concerns we’ve spent years solving with care, precision, and respect for the history of your home.

You’re welcome to text me directly at 978-265-5432. I can usually return your call within 24 hours, and you’re encouraged to send images or questions.

Prefer to schedule a site visit? You can book directly through our website at www.buildingrestorationservices.com.

If Your Boston Brownstone Could Speak…

Purpose: To help trustees, residents, and building managers in Boston-area brownstone condominiums identify, understand, and prioritize common structural and envelope issues that emerge in historic buildings. This guide is designed to build awareness, prompt early action, and support responsible stewardship of shared property.

ROOF + ROOFLINE

Roof Not Draining "My roof looks flat, but I just noticed water pooling up there after rain. Shouldn’t it be draining?"

Recommendation: Flat roofs are designed with a subtle slope to direct water to internal drains or scuppers. If water is pooling, it often means drains are clogged with debris, or there may be low points in the roof surface from sagging structural members or deterioration of the roof substrate. Clear all drainage points, inspect for membrane damage, and consider adding tapered insulation or re-pitching portions of the roof to ensure effective runoff.

Ice Dams and Stains "Our top-floor ceiling has started to stain after snow melts, but it doesn’t happen during summer storms. What’s going on?"

Recommendation: Ice damming occurs when heat from the building melts rooftop snow, which then refreezes at colder roof edges. This traps water under the membrane or shingles, causing interior leaks. Improve insulation in the top floor ceiling to reduce heat loss, seal attic air leaks that allow warm air to escape, and consider installing a waterproof membrane under the roof surface near eaves and parapets to protect against future backups.

Cornice Leaks "During heavy rain, I sometimes get leaks near the top of my bay window or just under the cornice."

Recommendation: Cornices and parapets are vulnerable to water intrusion if flashing is missing, corroded, or incorrectly lapped. Examine the intersection of roof edge, parapet wall, and cornice for gaps or deteriorated joints. Replace or reseal flashing, check the integrity of coping stones, and ensure water can shed properly without backing up behind decorative elements..

EXTERIOR WALLS

Zig-Zag Cracks "There’s a strange crack zig-zagging from the corner of my window up the wall. Is that settling?"

Recommendation: These stair-step cracks typically occur in brickwork and indicate movement in the wall assembly. This could be caused by foundation settlement, thermal expansion/contraction, or failure of supporting lintels. Have a structural inspection to determine the root cause. Repair methods may include masonry repointing, steel lintel reinforcement, or localized stabilization using masonry stitching techniques.

Rust Below Lintels "Rust stains are appearing below some windows. The bricks look cracked too."

Recommendation: Hidden steel lintels can rust when water infiltrates the wall. As steel corrodes, it expands and causes surrounding bricks to crack or push outward. Remove masonry over affected openings to assess lintel condition. Replace with galvanized or stainless-steel components where needed, and rebuild with original or matching brick and soft, lime-based mortar.

Bulging Brick Wall "There’s a bulge in the back wall—like it’s starting to bow outward."

Recommendation: Bulging usually results from separation between the inner and outer wythes of a multi-wythe brick wall, often caused by mortar failure, water damage, or structural overload. Assess the wall for tie rod failure or moisture intrusion. Stabilize by rebuilding damaged sections, reinstalling wall ties or using helical anchors, and repointing with compatible mortar.

Crumbly Brownstone "The brownstone surface is flaking around the windows."

Recommendation: This is a sign of delamination, common in brownstone due to its layered composition. Water penetrates and causes the surface to peel in thin sheets, especially under freeze-thaw cycles. Damaged areas should be carefully removed and patched with color-matched restoration mortar. Severely deteriorated elements may require full stone replacement using salvaged or newly quarried stone with matching mineral characteristics.

Ivy Damage "The ivy on the side wall looks charming, but I heard it might cause problems."

Recommendation: Ivy clings to masonry using root-like tendrils that penetrate mortar joints, accelerating decay and trapping moisture against the wall. Remove ivy by cutting it at the base and allowing it to die back naturally. After removal, inspect for biological staining and loose mortar. Repoint compromised joints and avoid replanting climbing vines directly on masonry.

Neighbor Separation "Hairline cracks are forming between our unit and the building next door."

Recommendation: These vertical cracks may indicate differential settlement between adjoining structures. Use telltale monitors to track movement over time. If active movement is detected, consider soil testing and targeted underpinning to stabilize foundations on the shifting side. Repoint cracked masonry joints using flexible lime mortar that accommodates subtle movement.

INTERIOR + STRUCTURE

Sagging or Creaky Floors "Our floors slope and creak in certain areas."

Recommendation: Sloping floors may result from joist deflection, wood shrinkage, or deterioration where joists meet masonry bearing walls. Inspect floor framing from below, looking for signs of rot, insect damage, or pulled connections. Solutions include sistering new lumber to existing joists, installing supplemental beams or posts, and ensuring that bearing pockets are dry and structurally sound.

Loose Stair Framing "The front stair feels wobbly and the handrail is loose."

Recommendation: Over time, vibration and moisture exposure can loosen connections between stair stringers and their supports. Carefully examine framing at the stair base and wall attachment points. Reinforcement may include adding concealed brackets, reinstalling newel posts with mechanical fasteners, and anchoring framing members securely to masonry or subfloor.

Cold Corners + Condensation "Our lower walls feel cold and wet in winter."

Recommendation: Solid masonry walls without insulation can conduct cold easily, leading to condensation on interior surfaces when warm indoor air meets cold walls. Install vapor-permeable interior insulation systems, such as mineral wool in wood furring channels, paired with smart vapor retarders. This approach preserves wall breathability and prevents trapped moisture.

Sagging Plaster Ceiling "A ceiling spot looks like it's about to fall—there's a bulge and cracks."

Recommendation: Historic plaster over wood lath is vulnerable to detachment due to age, water damage, or vibration. Use a plaster washer system to re-anchor partially detached areas, or remove and replaster if bulging is advanced. Match the existing texture and finish using traditional lime-gypsum plaster to retain historic character.

Interior Paint Peeling "Paint keeps bubbling and peeling on the inside walls."

Recommendation: Persistent interior paint failure is typically caused by moisture infiltrating from the exterior. Evaluate exterior masonry for cracks, failed flashing, or deteriorated mortar joints. Resolve the source of moisture before repainting. Choose breathable interior coatings like mineral or lime-based paints that allow vapor diffusion.

BASEMENT + FOUNDATION

Efflorescence "There’s white powder on the basement walls and the floor feels damp."

Recommendation: Efflorescence is the result of water carrying salts through masonry, which crystallize on interior surfaces. Identify the source of moisture—typically poor drainage, clogged downspouts, or ground contact. Apply lime plaster parging on interior surfaces to reduce evaporation zones and direct future repairs toward managing exterior moisture entry.

Basement Water "Water is pooling around the edges of our basement after storms."

Recommendation: Surface or groundwater infiltration is common in older foundations lacking waterproofing or drainage. Check for negative grading near the foundation, confirm gutters and downspouts discharge away from the building, and consider a perimeter French drain system with a sump pump. The system should include a vapor barrier and gravel base to alleviate hydrostatic pressure.

Pile Foundation Concerns "Our building might be on wood piles. How do we know if they’re okay?"

Recommendation: Many brownstones in Back Bay and the South End sit on untreated timber piles that remain sound only if permanently submerged. Conduct groundwater monitoring with a well or piezometer to ensure the pile tops remain below the water table. If levels drop, install deep foundation support such as micro-piles or helical piers to transfer load to stable strata.

STOOP + ENTRY

Tilting Steps "Our front steps look like they’re pulling away from the building."

Recommendation: Independent stoop footings may settle differently than the main foundation, causing gaps or step movement. Evaluate subsurface conditions and check for frost heave or water undermining. Stabilize with compacted fill, helical supports, or full rebuild of the stoop on reinforced footings tied back to the structure if necessary.

Slippery/Icy Steps "The steps stay icy longer than the sidewalk."

Recommendation: Brownstone steps often lack proper pitch or have deteriorated joints that trap moisture. Repoint treads and risers with soft mortar, reset stones to correct slope, and consider adding radiant heat cables beneath surface pavers. Always use de-icing products that are safe for natural stone (e.g., calcium magnesium acetate).

Loose Railings "The railings on the stoop are loose and feel unsafe."

Recommendation: Historic railings are commonly set into lead-filled sockets or stone mortises. Over time, anchors may loosen from corrosion or movement. Reset railing posts using traditional methods or epoxy grouts that match the original installation approach. Replication of missing components should be done in cast or wrought iron to preserve detail and code compliance.

PLANNING + PRESERVATION

Historic Rules Worry "I want to fix these issues but don’t want trouble with the historic commission."

Recommendation: Properties in Boston's historic districts must follow Landmarks Commission guidelines. Before beginning any exterior repair or alteration, consult the Commission’s application process and documentation requirements. Work with contractors who are experienced in preservation, and submit proposed materials, colors, and design details for approval. This avoids delays, ensures code compliance, and maintains neighborhood character.

The information provided on this website is intended for educational purposes only. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy and clarity, the insights, diagrams, and recommendations offered by Brownstone Whisperer do not constitute formal engineering, architectural, or legal advice.

Owners, trustees, and property managers should consult with licensed professionals before undertaking any repair, structural modification, or restoration activity. Every brownstone is unique—what appears to be a minor issue may require expert evaluation, and what seems urgent may, in fact, be stable.

When in doubt, seek the opinion of a qualified preservation contractor, structural engineer, or building scientist familiar with historic masonry construction and local codes.